Last month, I got a statement from a medical supply company in Duluth. I depend on them for durable medical equipment I use daily for a pretty personal reason. Since Medicare only allows a 90-day supply, I have to order four times a year, so I get four statements.
One side of the statement I just got lists an order I placed in late August, after Medicare processed the claim in early October. It shows what I owe for co-pays and my deductible.
The other side shows a similar order I placed last December. Medicare processed it in January, but I didn’t see the bill until October.
The company wants payment for both orders right away.
I didn’t see a bill for the medical supplies I ordered last December until late October this year. That reminded me of a press release from North Shore Health (NSH) called “The Life of a Healthcare Bill,” which ran in the Cook County newspaper on October 23.
NSH is a small, community-owned Critical Access Hospital and Care Center in Grand Marais. It’s the only hospital along about 110 miles of Lake Superior’s North Shore between Two Harbors, MN, and Thunder Bay, ON.
Almost everyone agrees the health care system in this country is broken. It played a big role in the recent election results.
In the past, doctors were independent members of the community. You could pay a doctor with sweet corn, a ham, or even a bottle of homemade spirits. Sometimes, you could work out a payment plan for when you had cash. But those days are gone.
If we fixed how health care payments work, it would help lower costs and ease the frustration people like me feel when the bills finally show up.
“The Life of a Healthcare Bill,” written by the hospital’s Director of Health Information, tries to answer a question patients ask all the time: “Why am I just getting this bill now? I was there months ago!” You can find it in the “News” section at northshorehealthgm.org.
The article explains how a small, rural hospital has to work just to stay open. It gives a step-by-step look at what happens after you go in for a lab test or hospital visit. While it tries to reassure patients that the system works as intended, it also shows that American healthcare financing is broken.
The author begins by contrasting healthcare with buying something at a store, where the price is known at checkout, and the transaction is finished. Instead, a single medical visit must survive an 11-stage obstacle course before the patient is ever told what they owe, including clinical documentation, medical coding, billing review, claim submission, insurance processing, denials or requests for more records, appeals, balance calculation, and—finally, weeks or months later—a bill in your mailbox.
Healthcare may be more like bringing your car into the shop to diagnose and repair whatever is causing the shimmy and squeak you hear when braking. You don’t know what the cost will be until after the diagnosis and remedy is done. But you see the bill when the work is done.
The people who handle coding for each insurance company at NSH do a great job. They work hard to make sure everything is right. They deserve credit for dealing with that maze every day.
The problem, and what needs to change, is the maze itself.
No other corner of the modern economy requires specialized translators, back-office “detectives,” and multi-month ping-pong matches between two bureaucracies just to generate an invoice.
Every insurance company has its own secret rate tables. Deductibles and coverage rules are always changing. Insurers often send claims back for more paperwork or deny them at first, dragging out the process while keeping the money people have paid for coverage. Healthcare isn’t especially mysterious. But we’ve ended up with a system that runs on secrecy, delays, denials, and huge profits for the insurance industry.
Stuck in the middle are two groups who never wanted all this red tape: local providers and local patients.
Small rural hospitals like NSH are stuck in this system. While a disputed code goes back and forth for months, NSH has already paid its nurses, doctors, and utility bills. Every dollar NSH spends on billing staff, coders, and appeals could instead help recruit doctors, update equipment, or keep local facilities open.
Across the country, about a quarter to a third of all healthcare spending gets lost in this black hole of administrative costs.
When surprise bills show up months after a visit, routine care can feel like a financial trap. Sometimes, it even makes people avoid going to the doctor at all.
NSH’s column is a real community service because it explains why billing delays happen. But if an industry has to write a newspaper column to explain why it takes four months to send a bill, the real lesson isn’t that patients should be more patient. It’s that the billing system is broken and there’s no good excuse for it.
Columnist Steve Fernlund is a retired business owner living in Duluth. He published the Cook County News Herald in Grand Marais at the end of the last century. You may email comments or North Shore news story ideas to him at steve.fernlund@gmail.com. See more at www.stevefernlund.com.

